---
title: Can real-world data enrich clinical trials?
description: By combining or contrasting data from traditional clinical trials with real-world data, you can enhance clinical insights.
image: https://blog.healthverity.com/hubfs/Enriching%20clinical%20trials%20with%20real-world%20data%20-%20Blog%20Page.png
---

Announcing HealthVerity Precision Event Alerts, a next-generation physician alerting solution. [Learn more](https://healthverity.com/news/healthverity-precision-event-alerts-launch/)

- [Contact](https://healthverity.com/contact/)
- [Sign In](https://marketplace.healthverity.com/login/?next=/marketplace/)

[![HealthVerity-Logo-Dark-3](https://blog.healthverity.com/hs-fs/hubfs/HealthVerity-Logo-Dark-3.png?width=1662&height=320&name=HealthVerity-Logo-Dark-3.png)](https://healthverity.com/)

- How We Help 
    - Featured Content 
          - [HealthVerity MarketplaceTM](https://healthverity.com/marketplace/healthverity-marketplace/)
          - [HealthVerity TaxonomySM](https://healthverity.com/taxonomy-portal/)
          - [Life Sciences](https://healthverity.com/life-sciences/)
          - [Identity Manager (HVID)](https://healthverity.com/identity-manager/)
    - Data Ecosystem 
          - [HealthVerity MarketplaceTM](https://healthverity.com/marketplace/healthverity-marketplace/)
          - [HealthVerity TaxonomySM](https://healthverity.com/taxonomy-portal/)
          - [Precision Event Alerts](https://healthverity.com/precision-event-alerts/)
          - [HealthVerity Mastersets](https://healthverity.com/mastersets/portal/)
          - [Media Measurement](https://healthverity.com/media-measurement/)
          - [Insurance Underwriting](https://healthverity.com/insurance-underwriting/)
    - Technology Products 
          - [Identity Manager (HVID)](https://healthverity.com/identity-manager/)
          - [HealthVerity FLOW](https://healthverity.com/flow/portal/)
          - [Governance Manager](https://healthverity.com/governance-manager/)
          - [Smart Contracts](https://healthverity.com/smart-contracts-manager/)
- Symphony 
    - Symphony Health Platform 
          - [Symphony Health Overview](https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/overview/)
          - [Integrated Dataverse](https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/integrated-dataverse-and-source-solutions/)
          - [Symphony HealthCloud](https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/health-technology-and-business-intelligence-solutions/)
    - Symphony Solutions 
          - [Health technology and business intelligence solutions](https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/health-technology-and-business-intelligence-solutions/)
          - [Integrated Dataverse and Source Solutions](https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/integrated-dataverse-and-source-solutions/)
          - [Brand strategy and sales](https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/optimize-brand-strategy-and-sales-effectiveness/)
          - [HealthRankings](https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/health-rankings/)
          - [Market access](https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/solve-market-access-challenges/)
          - [Patient Journey](https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/understand-the-patient-journey/)
          - [Medicines affordability](https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/making-medicines-more-affordable/)
    - Symphony Products 
          - [PayerSource®](https://blog.healthverity.com/hubfs/HealthVerity-Symphony-PDFs/HealthVerity-Symphony-Health-Factsheet-PayerSource.pdf)
          - [PrescriberSource®](https://blog.healthverity.com/hubfs/HealthVerity-Symphony-PDFs/HealthVerity-Symphony-Health-Factsheet-PrescriberSource.pdf)
          - [PatientSource®](https://blog.healthverity.com/hubfs/HealthVerity-Symphony-PDFs/HealthVerity-Symphony-Health-Factsheet-PatientSource.pdf)
          - [PatientSourceCompleteTM](https://blog.healthverity.com/hubfs/HealthVerity-Symphony-PDFs/HealthVerity-Symphony-Health-Factsheet-PatientSourceComplete.pdf)
          - [PatientSourceDUOTM](https://blog.healthverity.com/hubfs/HealthVerity-Symphony-PDFs/HealthVerity-Symphony-Health-Factsheet-PatientSourceDUO.pdf)
          - [Symphony FLEXTM](https://blog.healthverity.com/hubfs/HealthVerity-Symphony-PDFs/HealthVerity-Symphony-Health-Factsheet-Symphony-FLEX.pdf)
          - [CustomerSource®](https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/integrated-dataverse-and-source-solutions/)
          - [DiagnosticSource®](https://blog.healthverity.com/hubfs/HealthVerity-Symphony-PDFs/HealthVerity-Symphony-Health-Factsheet-DiagnosticSource.pdf)
          - [NonRetailSource®](https://blog.healthverity.com/hubfs/HealthVerity-Symphony-PDFs/HealthVerity-Symphony-Health-Factsheet-NonRetailSource.pdf)
    - Symphony Technology 
          - [Symphony HealthCloud](https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/health-technology-and-business-intelligence-solutions/)
          - [Synoma Data Integration](https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/health-technology-and-business-intelligence-solutions/)
          - [Vantage Applications](https://blog.healthverity.com/hubfs/HealthVerity-Symphony-PDFs/HealthVerity-Symphony-Health-Factsheet-Vantage-Applications.pdf)
          - [Metys](https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/health-technology-and-business-intelligence-solutions/metys/)
- Who We Serve 
    - [Life Sciences](https://healthverity.com/life-sciences/)
    - [Government](https://healthverity.com/government/)
    - [Insurance](https://healthverity.com/insurance/)
    - [Channel Partners](https://healthverity.com/channel-partners/)
    - [Data Ecosystem Partners](https://healthverity.com/data-ecosystem-partners/)
- Resources 
    - [HealthVerity Blog](https://blog.healthverity.com/)
    - [News & Events](https://healthverity.com/resources/news-and-events/)
    - [Resource Library](https://healthverity.com/resources/resource-library/)
    - [Publications](https://healthverity.com/resources/publications/)
    - [The IPGE Approach](https://healthverity.com/ipge-approach/)
    - [Zombie Data Explained](https://healthverity.com/get-verified/)
- [Careers](https://healthverity.com/careers/)
- [About Us](https://healthverity.com/about-us/)

[Request Demo](https://healthverity.com/request-demo/)

[Contact](https://healthverity.com/contact/) [Sign In](https://marketplace.healthverity.com/)

[![Logo](https://blog.healthverity.com/hubfs/social-suggested-images/healthverity.comwp-contentuploadshealthverity-2023-logo2x.png)](https://healthverity.com/)

- How We Help
- Symphony
- Who We Serve
- Resources
- [Careers](https://healthverity.com/careers/)
- [About Us](https://healthverity.com/about-us/)

[Request Demo](https://healthverity.com/request-demo/)

 Featured Content

<https://healthverity.com/marketplace/healthverity-marketplace/>

###### HealthVerity MarketplaceTM

 The nation’s largest healthcare and consumer data ecosystem

<https://healthverity.com/pathways/>

###### taXonomy Pathways

 Unique features per therapeutic area with claims, labs and EHR including notes

<https://healthverity.com/exos/>

###### HealthVerity eXOs

 AI-native real-world evidence generation

<https://healthverity.com/identity-manager/>

###### Identity Manager (HVID)

 Standalone de-identification as a service

 Data Ecosystem

<https://healthverity.com/marketplace/healthverity-marketplace/> HealthVerity MarketplaceTM

<https://healthverity.com/taxonomy-portal/> HealthVerity TaxonomySM

<https://healthverity.com/notes/> HealthVerity Notes

<https://healthverity.com/precision-event-alerts/> Precision Event Alerts

<https://healthverity.com/mastersets/portal/> HealthVerity Mastersets

<https://healthverity.com/media-measurement/> Media Measurement

<https://healthverity.com/audiences/> Syndicated Audiences

<https://healthverity.com/insurance-underwriting/> Insurance Underwriting

 Technology Products

<https://healthverity.com/identity-manager/> Identity Manager (HVID)

<https://healthverity.com/healthverity-for-clinical-trial-linkage/> HealthVerity for Clinical Trial Linkage

<https://healthverity.com/healthverity-for-commercial/> HealthVerity for Commercial

<https://healthverity.com/smart-contracts-manager/> Smart Contracts

<https://healthverity.com/healthverity-for-registries/> HealthVerity for Registries

 Symphony Health Platform

<https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/overview/>

###### Symphony Health Overview

 Seamless Data. Stronger Insights. Smarter Decisions.

<https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/integrated-dataverse-and-source-solutions/>

###### Integrated Dataverse

 Integrated Dataverse (IDV®) is de-identified claims data platform that combines medical, hospital, prescription, and demographic data into a single unifed view.

<https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/health-technology-and-business-intelligence-solutions/>

###### Symphony HealthCloud

 Securely store, integrate, access, and analyze virtually unlimited volumes of data with Symphony HealthCloud.

 Symphony Solutions

<https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/health-technology-and-business-intelligence-solutions/> Health technology and business intelligence solutions

<https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/integrated-dataverse-and-source-solutions/> Integrated Dataverse and Source Solutions

<https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/optimize-brand-strategy-and-sales-effectiveness/> Brand strategy and sales

<https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/health-rankings/> HealthRankings

<https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/solve-market-access-challenges/> Market access

<https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/understand-the-patient-journey/> Patient Journey

<https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/making-medicines-more-affordable/> Medicines affordability

 Symphony Products

<https://blog.healthverity.com/hubfs/HealthVerity-Symphony-PDFs/HealthVerity-Symphony-Health-Factsheet-PayerSource.pdf> PayerSource®

<https://blog.healthverity.com/hubfs/HealthVerity-Symphony-PDFs/HealthVerity-Symphony-Health-Factsheet-PrescriberSource.pdf> PrescriberSource®

<https://blog.healthverity.com/hubfs/HealthVerity-Symphony-PDFs/HealthVerity-Symphony-Health-Factsheet-PatientSource.pdf> PatientSource®

<https://blog.healthverity.com/hubfs/HealthVerity-Symphony-PDFs/HealthVerity-Symphony-Health-Factsheet-PatientSourceComplete.pdf> PatientSourceCompleteTM

<https://blog.healthverity.com/hubfs/HealthVerity-Symphony-PDFs/HealthVerity-Symphony-Health-Factsheet-PatientSourceDUO.pdf> PatientSourceDUOTM

<https://blog.healthverity.com/hubfs/HealthVerity-Symphony-PDFs/HealthVerity-Symphony-Health-Factsheet-Symphony-FLEX.pdf> Symphony FLEXTM

<https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/integrated-dataverse-and-source-solutions/> CustomerSource®

<https://blog.healthverity.com/hubfs/HealthVerity-Symphony-PDFs/HealthVerity-Symphony-Health-Factsheet-DiagnosticSource.pdf> DiagnosticSource®

<https://blog.healthverity.com/hubfs/HealthVerity-Symphony-PDFs/HealthVerity-Symphony-Health-Factsheet-NonRetailSource.pdf> NonRetailSource®

 Symphony Technology

<https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/health-technology-and-business-intelligence-solutions/> Symphony HealthCloud

<https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/health-technology-and-business-intelligence-solutions/> Synoma Data Integration

<https://blog.healthverity.com/hubfs/HealthVerity-Symphony-PDFs/HealthVerity-Symphony-Health-Factsheet-Vantage-Applications.pdf> Vantage Applications

<https://healthverity.com/symphony-health/health-technology-and-business-intelligence-solutions/metys/> Metys

<https://healthverity.com/life-sciences/>

###### Life Sciences

 Technology solutions from development through commercialization

<https://healthverity.com/channel-partners/>

###### Channel Partners

 HealthVerity enables partners to unlock unprecedented value and insights for clients

<https://healthverity.com/government/>

###### Government

 Comprehensive and compliant solutions to manage the nation’s care

<https://healthverity.com/data-ecosystem-partners/>

###### Data Ecosystem Partners

 Join the nation’s largest data partner ecosystem

<https://healthverity.com/insurance/>

###### Insurance

 Insurance-grade solutions that excel in managing risk and rebates

<https://blog.healthverity.com/>

###### HealthVerity Blog

 Insights and updates from industry experts

<https://healthverity.com/resources/publications/>

###### Publications

 Peer-reviewed research and discoveries

<https://healthverity.com/resources/news-and-events/>

###### News & Events

 Stay informed about our latest announcements and happenings

<https://healthverity.com/ipge-approach/>

###### The IPGE Approach

 Fundamentals that power everything that we do and every solution we offer

<https://www.healthverity.com/resources/resource-library/>

###### Resource Library

 Explore guides, webinars, and tools to enhance your understanding

<http://www.healthverity.com/get-verified>

###### Zombie Data Explained

 Learn how data quality drives better research outcomes

[Solutions & Best Practices](https://blog.healthverity.com/tag/solutions-best-practices)

# Can real-world data enrich clinical trials?

[By - HealthVerity,](https://blog.healthverity.com/author/healthverity)  May 4, 2021

![Can real-world data enrich clinical trials?](https://blog.healthverity.com/hubfs/Enriching%20clinical%20trials%20with%20real-world%20data%20-%20Blog%20Page.png)

COVID-19 urgently highlighted the need for real-time data, and with it, the need to tap into a wider variety of data sources to answer clinical questions has become abundantly clear. Traditionally, clinical trial data is gathered by participating researchers themselves according to the study protocol, regardless of the availability of relevant “outside” information that might enhance clarity of the findings. Therefore, in conventional clinical trials, useful information about the participating patients, such as prior real-world disease and treatment experiences, are necessarily omitted. Additionally, many trials don’t routinely continue to follow participants’ progress after the active treatment/evaluation period of the study.

Today’s data picture is excitingly different, as electronic health records, device data and patient-generated data enable us to learn so much about the prospective and retrospective patient journey. Real-world data and real-world evidence derived from sources that go beyond those of the individual participants in a clinical trial enhance the conclusions we can draw from trials, better guiding and influencing patient outcomes.

According to FDA, RWD is information relating to patient health status and/or the delivery of health care which is routinely collected from a variety of sources including electronic medical records, medical claims and billing, product and disease registries, mobile devices and from patients themselves. RWE, by contrast, is the clinical evidence about the use and potential benefits or risks of a medical product derived from analyzing RWD. RWD sources can be used to collect data and may allow for developing an analysis infrastructure to support many types of clinical trials.

## Using real-world data (RWD) and real-world evidence (RWE) to enhance clinical insights in clinical trials

Combining or contrasting data from traditional clinical trials with real-world data can garner many novel insights. By merging these siloed data points, and augmenting them with incremental licensed data, opportunities open up to learn more about patients pre- and post- study as well as during the active study period. How does the data tell this [patient journey](https://blog.healthverity.com/longitudinal-patient-journey-de-identified-patient-data) story? We begin with patient [consent](https://healthverity.com/solutions/healthverity-consent/), allowing the collection of data outside the realm of study data. Once consent has been obtained, data must be de-identified from sources such as payers or pharmacy claims or hospital chargemasters. And then the data needs to be linked across these disparate sources to ensure that all transactions belong to the same individual regardless of variances such as the number of times they may have moved, or changes in insurance providers. And finally, this data needs to be linked to study data. All in a HIPAA-compliant manner.

HealthVerity solutions make these scenarios easily possible, granting study investigators the ability to evaluate transactions relating to the patient retrospectively, before the study began, in real-time during the trial, and even prospectively after the trial concludes, to understand long-term ramifications. Our technologies grant the ability to evaluate retrospective patient data on study subjects upon enrollment, for example, gather real-time insights on efficacy and adverse effects during the trial, potentially link data from other trials, and afterwards, continue to follow up on how the patients are doing in the real-world, even beyond the limited parameters of extension arms. No patient is ever really “lost to follow up” with this unique ability to gain further insights. In addition, RWD allows for creating a “synthetic or observational arm” of a clinical study using data from a pool of relevant subjects who are not part of the enrolled trial participants. This can help with decision-making in multiple ways, including the feasibility of running additional trials to expand a treatment population. The following list shows just some of the possibilities afforded by adding real-world data to a well-designed clinical trial.

Key uses of RWD:

- Updating side effect rates post-launch
- Discovery of previously unknown side-effects
- Single-arm experimental trials
- Digital approvals
- Biosimilar development
- Improved patient selection
- Efficient data collection
- Assessing the gap between reported and clinical efficacy
- Efficacy in specific populations
- Post-trial long-term outcomes
- Establishing standards of care
- Evaluating the effect of payors on care
- Clinical decision support from the perspective of physicians, patients, and the community  setting

An important aspect of RWE relevant to today’s concerns, especially in the era of COVID-19, is the ability to improve the diversity of study subjects and researchers. Historically underrepresented groups, such as people of color, people with language barriers, or those with distrust of the healthcare system can now be reached and included in a culturally sensitive way. By building diversity into trials from the conception stage, research and marketing teams can receive the benefits that ensue from testing new drug therapies in the widest possible array of human beings—and including those who in particular may be likely real-world future users of the product—and in the past were overlooked altogether when trials were designed.

The [FDA’s RWE Program under the 21st Century Cures Act](https://www.fda.gov/science-research/science-and-research-special-topics/real-world-evidence) is ongoing, evaluating the potential use of RWD to generate real-world experience of product efficacy that can support new indications of existing drugs and biologicals, as well as supporting requirements for post-approval study. Under this mandate, the [HealthVerity Provider Diversity Index](https://healthverity.com/clinical-trials/#pdi) can address FDA guidance on minority inclusion in trials, identify investigators with more diverse patient populations and highlight physicians who are more likely to treat minority patients at higher risk.

## Partnering with HealthVerity

HealthVerity’s solutions provide the infrastructure our clients need to leverage the enhanced learnings RWD can provide. Based on the foundation of identity, privacy, governance and exchange, there is no faster or more accurate way to de-identify, match and link health data. Our solutions are comprehensive, managing consent, licensing RWD via HealthVerity Marketplace, through delivering[real-time identity matching and resolution technologies](https://healthverity.com/solutions/healthverity-census/)directly into the workflow with 10x greater accuracy, found nowhere else. [HealthVerity Marketplace](https://healthverity.com/solutions/healthverity-marketplace/) is the largest real-world data ecosystem, encompassing over 75 healthcare and consumer data sources, 150 billion transactions and 330 million US patients.

The role played in today’s healthcare marketplace by real-world data and real-world evidence will only expand in the coming decades, along with the need to work with a partner with expertise in maximizing its value.

###### Category

- [Solutions & Best Practices](https://blog.healthverity.com/tag/solutions-best-practices)
- [Trends & Insights](https://blog.healthverity.com/tag/trends-insights)
- [HEOR](https://blog.healthverity.com/tag/heor)
- [Thought Leadership](https://blog.healthverity.com/tag/thought-leadership)
- [Marketplace](https://blog.healthverity.com/tag/marketplace)
- [taXonomy](https://blog.healthverity.com/tag/taxonomy)
- [Industry Updates](https://blog.healthverity.com/tag/industry-updates)
- [Case Studies](https://blog.healthverity.com/tag/case-studies)
- [Commercial Pharmaceutical](https://blog.healthverity.com/tag/commercial-pharmaceutical)
- [Government](https://blog.healthverity.com/tag/government)
- [AI](https://blog.healthverity.com/tag/ai)
- [eXOs](https://blog.healthverity.com/tag/exos)
- [Audiences](https://blog.healthverity.com/tag/audiences)
- [taXonomy Pathways](https://blog.healthverity.com/tag/taxonomy-pathways)
- [Notes](https://blog.healthverity.com/tag/notes)
- [Rare Diseases](https://blog.healthverity.com/tag/rare-diseases)

###### Popular Post

- [The GLP-1 trend: What the real-world data reveals](https://blog.healthverity.com/the-glp-1-surge-what-the-real-world-data-reveals)
- [GLP-1 trends 2025: real-world data, patient outcomes & future therapies](https://blog.healthverity.com/glp-1-trends-2025-real-world-data-patient-outcomes-future-therapies)
- [Open claims vs. closed payer claims: What’s the difference?](https://blog.healthverity.com/open-claims-vs-closed-payer-claims)
- [What is Privacy Preserving Record Linkage (PPRL)?](https://blog.healthverity.com/what-is-privacy-preserving-record-linkage)
- [GLP‑1 real‑world data for obesity: A new standard for metabolic care](https://blog.healthverity.com/glp-1-real-world-data-for-obesity-a-new-standard-for-metabolic-care)

###### Subscribe

### Similar Blogs

[![How Longitudinal Patient Insights Transform Clinical Trials](https://blog.healthverity.com/hs-fs/hubfs/HealthVerity%20Plus%20-%20Medidata%20-%20Blog%20Thumbnail.png?width=352&name=HealthVerity%20Plus%20-%20Medidata%20-%20Blog%20Thumbnail.png)](https://blog.healthverity.com/bridging-clinical-and-real-word-data)

#### [How Longitudinal Patient Insights Transform Clinical Trials](https://blog.healthverity.com/bridging-clinical-and-real-word-data)

By [HealthVerity](https://blog.healthverity.com/author/healthverity) 12 February 2021

 COVID-19 has heightened the need for an expanded understanding of clinical trial populations and...

[READ MORE](https://blog.healthverity.com/can-real-world-data-enrich-clinical-trials)

[![The role of real-world data in advancement of Alzheimer’s treatments](https://blog.healthverity.com/hs-fs/hubfs/aiding-the-advancement-of-alzheimers-treatment-blog.png?width=352&name=aiding-the-advancement-of-alzheimers-treatment-blog.png)](https://blog.healthverity.com/the-role-of-real-world-data-in-advancement-of-alzheimers-treatments)

#### [The role of real-world data in advancement of Alzheimer’s treatments](https://blog.healthverity.com/the-role-of-real-world-data-in-advancement-of-alzheimers-treatments)

By [HealthVerity](https://blog.healthverity.com/author/healthverity) 3 April 2026

 One in nine Americans age 65 and older has Alzheimer’s disease (AD), a devastating illness that...

[READ MORE](https://blog.healthverity.com/can-real-world-data-enrich-clinical-trials)

[![Lessons Learned from COVID-19 Clinical Trials](https://blog.healthverity.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Lessons-Learned-from-COVID-19-Clinical-Trials.jpg?width=352&name=Lessons-Learned-from-COVID-19-Clinical-Trials.jpg)](https://blog.healthverity.com/lessons-learned-from-covid-19-clinical-trials)

#### [Lessons Learned from COVID-19 Clinical Trials](https://blog.healthverity.com/lessons-learned-from-covid-19-clinical-trials)

By [HealthVerity](https://blog.healthverity.com/author/healthverity) 13 December 2022

 The challenges of the COVID-19 pandemic did bring about some positive impact, accelerating the...

[READ MORE](https://blog.healthverity.com/can-real-world-data-enrich-clinical-trials)

#### Who we serve

- [Life Sciences](https://healthverity.com/life-sciences/)
- [Government](https://healthverity.com/government/)
- [Insurance](https://healthverity.com/insurance/)
- [Channel Partners](https://healthverity.com/channel-partners/)
- [Data Ecosystem Partners](https://healthverity.com/data-ecosystem-partners/)

#### How we help

- [HealthVerity Marketplace](https://healthverity.com/marketplace/)
- [HealthVerity Mastersets](https://healthverity.com/mastersets/)
- [HealthVerity FLOW](https://healthverity.com/flow/)
- [The IPGE Approach](https://healthverity.com/ipge-approach/)

#### Resources

- [HealthVerity Blog](https://blog.healthverity.com/)
- [News & Events](https://healthverity.com/resources/news-and-events/)
- [Resource Library](https://healthverity.com/resources/resource-library/)
- [Publications](https://healthverity.com/resources/publications/)

#### Our company

- [About Us](https://healthverity.com/about-us/)
- [Leadership](https://healthverity.com/about-us/#leadership)
- [Board of Directors](https://healthverity.com/about-us/#board)
- [Careers](https://healthverity.com/careers/)
- [Contact](https://healthverity.com/contact/)

©2026 HealthVerity, Inc.    |    [Terms & Conditions](https://healthverity.com/terms-and-conditions/)    |    [Privacy Policy](https://healthverity.com/privacy-policy/)

<https://twitter.com/healthverity> <https://www.linkedin.com/company/healthverity>

![](https://px.ads.linkedin.com/collect/?pid=4361946&fmt=gif)